Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Greenleaf's avatar

Chuck,

I was tempted to write a blog entitled “Contra Chuck Redux.” But I'll refrain (and who likes to read Latin anyway?). I'll make a few points here instead:

1. As a tactic to derail Trump, I'd be happy to see all Iowans--even Dems--go caucus for Haley. The first priority is to defend American democracy, the rule of law, avoid war; and to promote virtue (more on this last item in a bit). We support all of these aspirations and values by opposing Trump.

2. There is a Republican Party in name only; there's been an invasion of body snatchers that are best labeled MAGA. By registering as a Republican now, you're identifying with a cult, a new ersatz religion. Religion and politics don't mix. (Faith and politics can & should mix, but that's for another time.)

3. The viral infection that has snatched the body of the Republican Party won't disappear even if its primary vector--Defendant Trump--loses or is barred from the upcoming elections. The whole edifice--the current Republican Party--needs to be torched (metaphorically speaking). That will only occur if enough folks simply refuse to support or vote for candidates who don't reject Trump & all his works.

4. Haley has refused the call to reject Trump and all his evil works.

5. As Chris Christie said on his way out the door, she's not up to it. She wants to gain the nomination and then claim she's different from Trump (and imply that she can tame his voters and acolytes). If you intend to take down the king, you have to slay him (metaphorically speaking). She refuses to pick up the sword. How will she then rule?

7. On virtue: as you know, I've been reading my way through THE FEDERALIST PAPERS and some related secondary literature. The Founders built this republic with the understanding that virtue, public virtue, must serve as a cornerstone. Their confidence in virtue--including opposition to “faction” & “party”--quickly proved untenable. Most people, even the best among us, can not always act purely out of public-spirited virtue. But that being acknowledged, we can't survive as a representative democracy (republic) without some modicum of public virtue in our political leaders and citizens. Trump is the antithesis of virtue. He has no character (or is it a “bad character,” I'm not sure which way to go with that, but you get the idea). And because of the prevalence of so much lack of character or bad character abroad within the MAGA movement, to clean house we need a truly virtuous person to stand up and stand out. Of course, courage entails risk--ask Liz Cheney or Mitt Romney and the other Republicans who refused to kiss the ring. We've every reason to believe that Haley will not speak truth to power. We require a new profile in courage.

6. I commend to you this insightful article by Mark Leibovich in THE ATLANTIC (https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/01/nikki-haley-2024-campaign-primary-trump/677084/) that takes a close look at Haley.

So, I hope that Haley wins in Iowa, gains the nomination, and then loses the election. American politics more usually presents us with a series of binary choices, about which we sometimes feel too constrained, abut in this election, I see easy choices.

All the best,

Steve

Expand full comment
Richard Gilbert's avatar

Chuck—You’re a braver man than I am. 😀

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts